Baker Bettie

Fresh Strawberry Pie

Fresh strawberry pie is the epitome of spring! This pie is filled with tons of fresh berries and no need for jello! All of the flavor comes from the berries in this beauty of a pie! 

A whole Fresh Strawberry Pie with a heart shaped piece of pie crust as decoration on top

A couple of weeks ago, it refused to be spring in Chicago. It was ridiculously cold for being the first of April and we even got another dusting of snow.

To be fair, I was fully aware of Chicago’s long winters pre-move, but that doesn’t mean I wasn’t grumpy about it. I wanted sunshine! I wanted patio weather! I was more ready than I had ever been for it to really feel like spring!

So on a gloomy day off, I was bound and determined to make it feel like spring even if the weather insisted that winter was still here. I put away my winter coat for the season, vowing not to bring it back out again until at least October, and I purchased a whole load of strawberries. (Luckily my grocery store is next door to our building so running out in the cold without my coat wasn’t too terrible.)

Fresh strawberries in a colander

I like to think I had a little bit to do with the change of the weather for the better! I feel I willed the warm weather to come and stay. It is now full on spring here and I am loving every minute of it.

This fresh strawberry pie is 100% a necessity for you this spring and summer. You HAVE to make this! It is incredible. My mouth is watering just thinking about it.

I had actually never made a strawberry pie before and I was skeptical about how much I would like it. But holy wow. It was like a dream. One of the best pies I’ve ever tasted! MAKE THIS! You will want to hug and kiss me and squeeze me for commanding you to do so.

Logo for 'Better Homes 2015 Blogger Awards: Top Ten Baking'

Another cool thing that happened in the last couple of weeks, besides me making the pie of my dreams, is Baker Bettie was named in the top 10 of Better Homes & Gardens Blogger Awards for Best Baking Blog. Somehow I didn’t receive all the emails telling me I was even nominated. I found out towards the end of the voting period by someone congratulating me on being nominated.

I am so incredibly honored that so many people voted without me even having to beg you to do so! Thank you! This means to world to me and also means that I need to get my booty in gear and manage my time when I’m not working better to bring you all more recipes! I’m on it. I owe it to you. You guys are my favorite!

Collage of pictures: whole strawberry pie, fresh strawberries and a piece of strawberry pie

Ok, now onto this pie….

Pie crust dough in bowl

First you want to start by making a dough for a single pie crust. I highly recommend using my Basic Pie Dough Recipe. It is my favorite and extremely simple to make!

Pie crust crimped in pie tin

Then you are going to fit the dough into your pie plate and try and make it look all pretty. But don’t stress about the pretty part. This pie is rustic. It will taste amazing no matter what your crust looks like. But I highly recommend following my tutorial on How to Keep Your Pie Crust From Shrinking if that is something you usually have problems with!

Dock the dough with a fork all around the bottom and around the sides. Brush the edges of our pie crust with an egg white wash, then lay a piece of parchment paper in the crust and fill with pie weights, dry beans, or rice. Bake until golden brown and allow to cool completely before filling.

Fresh strawberries in colander

While you pie is baking and cooling, let’s get onto these strawberries!

Sliced strawberries in a bowl

(ignore my terrible kitchen lighting please!) Take half of your cleaned strawberries and cut them into small pieces. Save the other half to the side for later.

Strawberries and sugar in pan on stove

Toss the cut strawberries with sugar, cornstarch, a large pinch of salt, lemon zest, and lemon juice and put in a large saucepan over medium heat. You will cook these for about 10 minutes, until very thick and glossy. It may take a bit longer depending on how juicy your strawberries were.

Remaining fresh strawberries in colander

While your luscious strawberry filling is simmering on the stove, take that other half of strawberries you reserved and slice them in half. ONLY in half.

Fresh strawberries added to cooked strawberry mixture

Allow the cooked filling to cool slightly and then combine the halved strawberries with the finished cooked filling.

Filling added to cooked pie crust

Once the filling and the crust have cooled to room temperature, pour the filling into the crust and let it set in the refrigerator for at least 3 hours.

That’s it! No strawberry flavored jello needed. All the flavor of this baby comes straight from the strawberries! The lemon juice and zest helps bring out their natural flavor and you really don’t need to add any fake flavoring to a pie filled with this many luscious berries!

Scrap pie crust turned into heart shapes for decoration

If you prefer to have a double crust situation for this pie, here is what I suggest you do next. Roll out another piece of pie dough and cut out some shapes. Lay them on a sheet tray, brush with an egg white wash, sprinkle with sugar, and bake until golden brown.

Your pie filling is not going to be baked, so what you can do is take the pieces of baked pie crust and arrange them on the top of the pie once it starts to set.

Once my pie was all ready to go, I decided for just 1 little piece of pie crust on top as decoration. I wanted all those beautiful strawberries to shine through. Then I just snacked on the rest of the baked pie pieces like cookies which was equally as good of a use for them!

A whole Fresh Strawberry Pie with a heart shaped piece of pie crust as decoration on top

I decided to top pieces of my pie with sweetened whipped ricotta cheese. It didn’t get super thick and hold up like whipped cream, but man was it good! I mean, fruit and cheese. Duh! I highly recommend you trying it to.

And MAKE THIS PIE! I’m telling you. You won’t regret it.

A slice of the Fresh Strawberry Pie topped with cream

A slice of Fresh Strawberry Pie topped with cream

Fresh Strawberry Pie

Yield: 8-10 Servings
Prep Time: 3 hours 30 minutes
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 3 hours 45 minutes

Fresh strawberry pie is the epitome of spring! This pie is filled with tons of fresh berries and requires no need for jello. All of the flavor comes from the berries in this beauty of a pie! 


For the Pie Crust

  • 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
  • kosher salt
  • 1/2 cup shortening
  • ice water

For the Strawberry Filling

  • 3 lbs fresh strawberries
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 6 TBSP cornstarch
  • 1/4 tsp kosher salt
  • zest of half a small lemon
  • juice of half a small lemon


For the Crust

    For the Filling

      Leave a Reply

      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

      This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

      7 comments on “Fresh Strawberry Pie”

      1. Will definitely be trying this one! Looks lovely!

      2. wooooooooooo! you’re incredible!!!

        and omgosh this pie is stunning. so sooo pretty!

      3. This pie is so pretty and looks so delicious! Beautiful capture of the pie!

      4. Congratulations on making the top 10 awesome little bakers and what a way to celebrate with this beautiful seasonal strawberry pie. I know the weather is well…you know… but if it makes you feel any better my friend in Michigan took a photo of her husband cutting the grass and it started to snow…Hope you are doing well. Take Care, BAM

      5. Hi there! I made this pie today, it looked exactly like your pictures, except I added a few more hearts on top and I organized the fresh strawberries in circle at the bottom and on top of the pie. Unfortunately it looked much better than it tasted, it was much too sweet and I’m not sure those I baked for were sold on the whole cornstarch texture. I’m now left with half a pie that won’t be eaten, so about 1.5lb of strawberries wasted. Too bad, the dessert looked amazing!

      6. You totally deserve that award. A huge congrats! This pie is summer. I want so badly to attack it with a knife. Pinned.

      7. Nothing beats the great flavor coming from the fresh strawberries! I am so loving this pie and is very perfect for the berry season. This is really a summer pie!

      Leave a Comment »