Baker Bettie

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie

This is my recipe for the best creamy pumpkin pie! In my opinion this is THE pumpkin pie to end all pies! The filling is luscious, silky, and totally decadent. Find out the secret ingredients to make this pie over the top!

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie Recipe- Baker Bettie

I want you to listen to me closely. If you are making pumpkin pie this week you should make this one. I’m serious. I’m seriously serious. This is THE pumpkin pie. It is creamy and spicy and sweet and full of Fall in every bite. Again I say: This is THE pumpkin pie. Am I making myself clear?

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie Recipe- Baker Bettie

Yeah sure. I know what you are thinking. It looks like an ordinary pumpkin pie right? Well stop thinking that! Just stop right now. Because this pumpkin pie is on a whole new level.

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie Recipe- Baker Bettie

It starts with cream cheese. Just enough cream cheese to add a wonderful creamy texture but not too much that it starts to move toward a cheesecake flavor. It also combines both pumpkin and candied yams as part of the filling.

It is a hybrid pie. It brings the fall spices that all pumpkin pies must have along with the molasses (from the brown sugar) that most sweet potato pies bring to the party. A touch of heavy cream (and by a touch, I mean, almost a whole cup of it) is swirled into the batter to up the creamy and decadent factor.

Finally, I added just a touch of dark rum because…do I really need to explain that?! It isn’t absolutely necessary in the recipe, but I highly recommend doing it. THE pie really is just perfect. Just absolutely perfect.

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie Recipe- Baker Bettie

You’re all adults here and can make your own decisions. But if I could tell you what to do, I would demand that you make this pie instead of the one off the back of the can. Don’t make that pie. Just don’t. It’s the holidays and this is no time for ordinary!

Also, it’s nice to share. I shared with Wyatt. (well, I let him lick the plate) He loved it.

Perfectly Creamy Pumpkin Pie- Baker Bettie

We’re headed to Kansas this week to see all of our family and friends. I couldn’t be more excited. I hope you all will have a relaxing holiday with family and friends as well!

I am thankful for each of you that visits my blog. You make blogging so exciting and rewarding. I love you all!

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie Recipe- Baker Bettie

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie Recipe- Baker BettieThe Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie Recipe- Baker Bettie

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie

The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie

Yield: 1- 9" Pie
Prep Time: 30 minutes
Cook Time: 1 hour 30 minutes
Total Time: 2 hours

This is my recipe for the best creamy pumpkin pie! In my opinion this is THE pumpkin pie to end all pies! The filling is luscious, silky, and totally decadent. Find out the secret ingredients to make this pie over the top!


For the Crust

  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1/4 tsp kosher salt
  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • 2/3 cup cold unsalted butter, cut into small pieces
  • ice water

For the Pumpkin Filling

  • 8 oz cream cheese, room temperature
  • 15 oz can pumpkin puree
  • 15 oz can candied yams, drained and mashed
  • 3/4 cup dark brown sugar
  • 1/4 tsp kosher salt
  • 1 tsp pumpkin pie spice
  • 1 TBSP dark rum (optional)
  • 1 egg, plus 2 egg yolks
  • 1/4 cup melted butter
  • 3/4 cup heavy cream


For the Crust

  1. Preheat the oven to 350ºF.
  2. In a large bowl, whisk together flour, salt, and sugar. Cut the butter into the flour mixture using a pastry cutter until it is the texture of coarse meal. Stir in water into the mixture 1 TBSP at a time until the dough starts to form into a ball.
  3. Gently roll out the dough into a circle and place in a 9? deep dish pie plate. Trim and crimp the edges. Prick the dough with a fork all over the bottom and the sides. Place in the freezer for 10 minutes until firm.
  4. Place a piece of parchment paper over the pie dough and fill with rice, dried beans, or pie weights. Place the pie plate on a baking sheet and bake at 350ºF for 12 minutes. Remove the pie weights and parchment paper and place back in the oven until browned. About 10 more minutes. Allow to cool on a wire rack before adding the filling.

For the Filling

  1. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a paddle attachment, beat the cream cheese until smooth and creamy. Add the pumpkin and the yams and beat until smooth, scraping down the bowl.
  2. Add the dark brown sugar, salt, pumpkin pie spice, and rum and mix until incorporated. Scrape down the bowl. Add the egg and egg yolks and the butter. Stir in the heavy cream.
  3. Over a large bowl, pour the mixture through a fine mesh sieve. Use a rubber spatula to force the mixture through the sieve.
  4. Pour into the pre-baked pie shell and bake at 350ºF for 75-90 minutes or until set and no longer jiggly in the middle.
  5. Cool on a wire rack at room temperature. Serve with whipped cream.
Nutrition Information:

Amount Per Serving:Calories: 660

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

27 comments on “The Best Creamy Pumpkin Pie”

  1. I am quite intrigued with the addition of cream cheese. This recipe is very similar to my family recipe, but we use a bit more heavy cream and no cream cheese. I would really like to try this! Thanks & Happy Thanksgiving!

  2. Making my pies tomorrow, this sounds delicious! I’m going to try it!!! Thank you!!

  3. I love the way you blog & I have loved pumpkin pie since I met an Aussie American family when our girls started preschool together all those years ago but the thing I really love is that you co-chef with your cat – you are a girl with style

    I’ll rate it when I make it but sounds divine

    • Tell me the difference between canned Pumpkin & pumkin you pick from the garden & are candied yams anything like what Aussies call Sweet Potatoes?
      I would love to know


      • there are many types of pumpkins. You do not want to use the type of pumpkin you use to carve for jack-0-lanterns, they don’t have much pulp, and flavor is lacking. Baby Bears, or Cinderella pumpkins are best. they dont have as many seeds, and lots of pulp. You also have to cook your raw pumpkin before using in a pie. I roast mine. cut them in half, take out seeds, leave in the stringy stuff. place cut side down in roasting pan and cook at 400 – 450 degrees for a few hours. time to roast depends on size of pumpkin and whether you roast both halves at the same time. Flavor is so much better with fresh pumpkin. You also need to drain it really well after roasting to get as much water out as possible. I just put mine in a strainer lined with a coffee filter over a pot and let it sit. hope this helps!

  4. This does sound like a scrumdiddlyumptious pie! This year I already have pies with gingerbread crust on the menu, one vegan and the other not. This will make next year’s for sure.

  5. Thanks for sharing! I will be making this today for Thursday’s Thanksgiving feast!

  6. WHOA. I have never seen a pumpkin pie like this before–so cool and it looks so beautiful and delicious!!! Gahhhhh now I wish I was making it!

    (btw I’ll probs still be living in the nyc until the end of March soooo you should visit sometime before then 😛 :D)

  7. Pingback: 10 Holiday Pumpkin Recipes « Keitochan Says:

  8. Well, I made this pie a couple of days ago. Unfortunately, I was not as impressed as I expected to be. The amount of molasses that is used resulted in a pie that tasted like a molasses pie, not a pumpkin pie. I’m not certain what kind of molasses you use (yes, there are different kinds). The only molasses available at my grocers is black strap molasses. I purchased the mildest variety possible. If I make this again, I would definitely cut back on the molasses to maybe 1 tablespoon, or 1 1/2. I am certain if I had sorgum molasses (which is not nearly as strong in flavor), this would have turned out very good.

    • I’m guessing it must have been the type of molasses you used and this is a good point because there are definitely varying strengths of molasses. When I made it the first time I thought it could actually use a little more because the molasses flavor was so very subtle. I actually made this again since writing this recipe and post and this time I used dark brown sugar because I didn’t have molasses on hand where I was baking. I thought it was a good substitution because the brown sugar had the molasses already mixed in. It turned out just as good. I will edit the recipe to this version to eliminate the possible problem someone else might have with it. Thank you for the feedback and I’m sorry it didn’t work out the way you hoped.

  9. I made this on Thanksgiving and thought it was, AMAZING!!!!!!!! I am locking this recipe away and making this one again and again!!!!!! TY you so much! LOVE,LOVE, LOVED it!! it was a huge hit!!!!!!

  10. cream cheese and heavy cream would make this the best pumpkin pie ever!

  11. I’m from Canada – I’ve never seen anything like candied yams. If I ever make a trip to the States – where in the grocery store would you find this and do different brands make a difference?

    Thank you.

  12. I made this tonight for mom and dad who are in town visiting my sister and me. It was a huge hit. Everyone loved it. I used a dark anejo rum that I thoroughly enjoyed sipping on while preparing this beautiful pie. Oh and before I forget, I love your blog! I love reading your stories and the photos are beautiful.

  13. I made this last week, as a test run for Thanksgiving. It is definitely a keeper! I took it to work so I would be tempted by so much pie at home. Everyone loved it. One coworker said it beat her pie, which was hard to do. I made the pie with one difference, I exchanged 2 2/3 Tbsp butter in the crust for lard.
    I got a lot of complements on the crust, too.

  14. Pingback: No-Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake Filling - Baker Bettie

  15. Pingback: Creamy Herbed Mashed Potatoes - Baker Bettie

  16. Pingback: Cookie Christmas Tree, Sour Cream Sugar Cookies- Baker Bettie

  17. is it okay to use fresh pumpkin instead of in can? what procedure i am going to do? thanks.

  18. idk what went wrong with the crust 🙁 it was a buttery mess i followed all the instructions to a T but the crust was awful

  19. I’m excited to try this tomorrow! The only thing that I will say so far is I doubled the recipe because I am taking 2 tomorrow, and I had SO much filling left over to fill another deep dish pie shell. I hated to waste it but really didn’t need another pie. Other than that the filling has a good taste to it 🙂

  20. Thank you for the recipes. Luv the site 

Leave a Comment »